ALL CANDIDATE MEETINGS
Oct 5 Cumberland All Candidates Meeting
My prepared statements
Opening remarks
I’d like to thank all of you for coming tonight, and thanks to those of you who trusted me with your vote four years ago. It is not a responsibility I take lightly.
I’ve been asked to speak a little bit about how Cumberland is changing. Well, for me, the biggest change has been that Cumberland has grown, is growing and shows no signs of stopping.
I believe that growth is going to happen regardless of what we do as a council. The question isn't whether Cumberland is going to change. The question is how we manage that change.
We cannot stick Cumberland in amber and expect it to stay exactly the way it is.
No matter how much we want that. I'd like that too! I think we all agree - we like how walkable and friendly, how “villagey” this community is, and I don’t want to lose that. But I don’t think the choice is between growth and no growth - if we vote down every development things will change as well, they will just change in a different way. Perhaps housing prices will go up. People will move away. And there will be fewer taxpayers to shoulder the burden of our rising costs - which are mostly due to factors beyond our control. Bloody inflation!
The status quo is not an option.
The real choice is what sort of change we want - do we want more single family sprawl? Or do we want more density - which allows us to better manage our infrastructure?
Do we want housing to become even less affordable than it is already? Or do we want to provide a diversity of housing options, so everyone has a chance to call this home.
What I want is to manage the growth in a way that benefits the community as a whole. This is why I voted for the new OCP and zoning bylaw that brought in an urban containment boundary so we can reduce expensive sprawl. This is why I want to see more housing options in Cumberland, so we don’t lose many of the people who make Cumberland what it is.
My goal is to make sure that as Cumberland changes, we’re the ones managing that change - not simply reacting to it.
Closing remarks
In closing, I want to reflect on some of the things we’ve heard tonight.
People are concerned about affordability. They’re concerned about food security and what Cumberland is going to look like in the future. They’re concerned about the costs of infrastructure and policing, about taxes, and about making sure that Cumberland remains Cumberland.
I think some of these reflect and are born of the changes that are happening in Cumberland, and that I talked about in my opening statement. And I’ve tried to explain where I stand on these issues.
I recognize that times are hard for many of us right now, and none of us really know exactly what’s coming in the future. But I do believe that a Council that is willing to look at the big picture, listen to the community, and make difficult decisions based on both the short and long-term interests of Cumberland can navigate us forward.
I’m still the guy that likes curling up with my cat and a 300-page agenda. Over the last four years I’ve done the work. I’ve tried to listen and take in all the input I can before making my decisions, and I’ve tried to imagine how today's decisions are going to affect Cumberland in 20, 30, 50 years.
We’ve accomplished a lot over the last four years. We’ve built a new wastewater treatment facility. We’ve invested in streets and sidewalks. We completed a new OCP and zoning bylaw that gives us a framework for managing growth and protecting the things that make Cumberland special, but the work continues.
So when you go to vote, I would encourage you to vote for people who are collaborative, consultative and open-minded. People who show up in the community, listen to different perspectives, and can see the big picture.
I think that’s me. Thank you.
Questions and answers
The following responses are not verbatim transcriptions but rather a summary of what I said, plus what I wish I had said!
YOUTH ISSUES IN THE VILLAGE
Council doesn’t have a lot of levers to use. Vandalism and break-ins are police matters, so a community approach where we let parents know what their kids are doing is probably going to be our best way forward. It takes a village. Mayor Brown is working with the dirt biking community on land access.
I also wish I had mentioned that we have lots of great facilities for youth to use, including skate parks, jump parks, basketball courts, and, of course, miles of bike trails.
DECIDING ON ISSUES OUTSIDE TYPICAL VILLAGE RESPONSIBILITIES
It comes from the heart. Is this something we should be advocating for? If it is, then yes, let’s use our voice and advocate for it. Is it the right thing to do? If I believe it is, then I’m going to be in favor of trying to do it. We saw that when the CVRD came to us asking for space for a warming center.
I also wish I had said that I’m pleased we are funding the Beaufort Clinic. Having a clinic in town is a great asset for our community.
ON THE SAFETY OF WOMEN, GIRLS AND GENDER-DIVERSE PEOPLE IN OUR COMMUNITY
As men, we have to take responsibility for this issue. We have to be willing to call out those behaviors when we see them. We need to support girls and gender-diverse people in our schools, as well as the educators who are trying to support them. We need to educate our children on these issues because this isn’t going away until the culture changes.
Nick nailed it when he said, “Everybody in society needs to feel safe, especially our most vulnerable.”
FOOD AND WATER SECURITY
We only have a couple of days of food supply on the Island. By shopping local, we can encourage more local food supply. There are opportunities for larger commercial food production in Bevan. On the topic of water security, the Village is working with Mosaic to ensure a healthy watershed and preserve our drinking water into the future.
I also wish I had mentioned the Cumberland Community Schools Society Food Share program, which is helping some of our vulnerable population access healthy food.
PUBLIC ART SPACES
I like the idea of an outdoor stage. The first step toward getting one will be to complete an arts and culture master plan. The hard part of this is going to be funding it. It’s true that every dollar invested returns three, but those dollars are invested by the Village, while the return comes to the community. So community fundraising and grants will be needed to get this off the ground.
Zanoni made a good point that this may be a difficult ask in a down economy.
AFFORDABILITY IN CUMBERLAND
We have to be realistic. Houses are expensive. The best we are going to be able to do is try to mitigate the problem by encouraging more housing types in the Village: more ADUs, more townhouses, and more apartments. This is what we tried to do with our new OCP and urban containment boundary. By providing more affordable options, hopefully more people can remain in Cumberland.
WOULD YOU SUPPORT A COMMUNITY INITIATIVE FOR A RAINBOW CROSSWALK?
Yes, I would support this initiative. Cumberland should be a welcoming community for everyone.
ALL CANDIDATE MEETINGS
Sept 21 Comox Valley Chamber of Commerce
My prepared responses
On improving affordability and housing: Housing affordability and housing supply are closely related. I see the village's role as trying to create the right conditions to allow a diversity of housing options - we tried to do this with the new OCP and zoning bylaws, for example, four units are now permitted on most single family lots within the urban containment boundary and there are many multifamily zoned lots within the boundary as well. We continue to work with senior government to fund housing projects.
On growth and ageing infrastructure: It’s important that we recognise the limits of what we can reasonably ask from taxpayers. As we saw from the recent decision to delay the Penrith project our current cost estimates for projects don’t line up with reality. In general I believe new development should pay for new infrastructure and we have DCCs and ACCs to help ensure that happens. We also need to continue to aggressively apply for grant funding for larger projects as our limited tax base simply cannot afford everything we need.
On regional collaboration: I have been a strong proponent of regional cooperation when it makes sense - things like waste management, emergency management, hospitals, regional parks and so on. But some things require a distinctly Cumberland approach, local matters such as fire, zoning, heritage, arts and culture, forest stewardship.
On supporting economic development: I think our role is to foster those conditions, yes. In our new OCP and zoning bylaws, we have a new MU2 zone that expands the commercial core. I think we should work with the Chamber, of course! I believe we are currently participating in the Cumberland business retention and expansion initiative. My hope is that this project will produce actionable items that we can implement to make conditions better for everyone.
Development processes and timelines: Yes I think reducing red tape (duplicative requirements, for example) is a good idea and any way we can encourage feedback from businesses to streamline would be helpful. To that end - please fill out those surveys!!! We have already delegated minor variance approvals to staff, but there is a limit to what hurdles we can remove while maintaining zoning and regulatory control. It is still important that we develop with care and oversight in order to maintain Cumberland’s unique charm. We have obtained grants and are still working on modernizing these processes.
QUESTIONS FROM THE CUMBERLANDER
The Cumberlander is a new free print-only broadsheet in Cumberland. In their second issue, they published a series of questions and answers from all the candidates. Here are my answers:
Policing costs and the reserve: In general, I always prefer having a cushion in reserves, especially for future known costs. Unfortunately, policing costs are currently still very uncertain in size and timing, and what we add to that cushion in reserve depends on a large number of other budgetary concerns as well.
Development, DCCs and growth: Landowners determine the pace of development; and the Official Community Plan guides the extent and character of that development. There is an urban containment boundary in the new OCP that I hope will reduce sprawl (which imposes costs on existing taxpayers). DCCs (and ACCs) help apportion costs between developers and taxpayers and, yes, developers need to pay their fair share of costs.
Council power, staff and public input: We have to balance reserving council discretion against efficient decision making and cost-prohibitive red tape - straight-forward minor issues that can be safely delegated to staff can and should be.
Consensus and dissent: Consensus is neither a strength nor a weakness. It is simply the outcome of staff work that meets the goals that were set during the strategic planning done each term - staff have been excellent at understanding those goals and moving them forward appropriately. I have stood alone on the Comox Lake Land Corporation issue where I voted against moving ahead given the many bylaw infractions still unresolved. I feel that overlooking non-compliance sets a challenging precedent. Solutions must reinforce accountability and fairness for all.
Grants and infrastructure priorities: Sidewalks, bike lanes and traffic calming are basic infrastructure - and they are typically a small fraction of the overall cost, but including them often unlocks those large 60% grants. We try to reduce costs by pairing below-grade work with concurrent street repairs and upgrades. We often have to wait on projects until the grants are available or they would be unaffordable.
Online harms: The Village is and should be limited in its involvement in online discussion. It is hoped that participation in the Strong Cities Prevention Academy will help us improve operational safety, crisis management, and community well-being - it is not a way to curtail lawful online expression. Cumberland’s Engagecomoxvalley.ca is the platform to review and discuss current projects; my inbox is always open as a councillor and I respond to any and all direct emails.
One decision you would change: Looking back, I don’t see any significant decisions where I would have voted differently today. I would have liked to have made room for more opportunities to engage with community during the OCP and Bylaw process, especially toward the later stages. However, provincial timelines made that difficult.
One promise: Rational, fact-based decision making. I promise I won’t do something just because of “vibes”. I will continue to represent all the residents to the best of my ability, my decisions will be made with the lens of what is best for the long term health of the village while still respecting the needs of the residents.
An uncontested mayoral race: Running for any elected position is not an easy decision to make - especially the role of mayor, and especially against someone who puts in as much time and has been as effective as Mayor Brown.
QUESTIONS FROM OTHER ORGANISATIONS
Comox Valley Record
Troy Therrien hopes to be re-elected to Cumberland Council
Decafnation.ca
2026 Cumberland candidates respond
Comox Valley Cycling Coalition
Supporting active transportation policies
Comox Valley Food Policy Council in partnership with LUSH Valley
All-Candidates Food Security Survey Results
Comox Valley Social Planning
All areas and Cumberland responses
Comox Valley Pickleball Association
Link to be posted once responses go live. As a member of the CVPBA, I support expanding pickleball in the valley. As a councillor, I know budgets are tight, but recreation is an important aspect of the services we provide.
Fair Care Alliance
Link to be posted once responses go live. North Island residents should not have to travel to Victoria for life saving treatments.
The Discourse
Link to be posted once responses go live.
CUPE 556
Link to be posted once responses go live. As a member of Cumberland council, we negotiated a fair CUPE contract that both provided a fair wage to your members and a sustainable and predictable expense for the village. I am hopeful that our next round of negotiations in three years can be mutually beneficial as well. CUPE does a good job advocating for its membership, and strong unions are the backbone of public service. As much as possible, I prefer our core services are delivered by village staff. A good working relationship among council, our employee the CAO, and their staff is in everyone’s best interest. Fair wages, benefits, and working conditions are a base line. Budgets have to be balanced with that as a given.
Want to know more?
If there is a question you have that you don't see the answer to, please reach out. I am always happy to have feedback - good, bad, or otherwise - and engage in constructive dialogue. As a councillor, being held accountable is part of the job.